Where he ends up in the January windowEvery outcome by the January deadline, adding up to 100%. A move in a later window is not counted. Open a club for its rumour.
Reporting1 trusted reporterDennis BayerFor the move
ContractRuns to June 20281 year 7 months left
FiorentinaSpending close to its limitAgainst the move
FeeReported €5mValue €4m
The story so far
2 reports · newest first
17Nov
Sport WitnessTrust55AggregatorAggregatorFull post ↗
“Birmingham City star seen as cheaper option for January transfer.. Birmingham City’s Phil Neumann has seen his future come into question in the past few weeks. The list of suitors for the defender is now growing.”
In the article“Today’s print edition of Gazzetta dello Sport looks at Fiorentina’s need to sign a new defender soon.”
10Nov
Dennis BayerTrust72First reportFirst reportFull post ↗
“#Sky Info: There is increasing interest in Phil #Neumann. Played every game for #Birmingham in the #Championship this season. #Fiorentina, #Nottingham and other teams gathered information about the CB. Winter move is a possibility.”
Chance it happens in January
3%
Long shot
Reported fee
€5m
Value
€4m
Powered by
AuthorTransfer Tracker AnalystLast updated18 Nov 2026StatusUp to date
Fiorentina see Neumann as cut-price fallback, not priority target
The situation
Fiorentina's interest in Phil Neumann has not gone away, but the latest reporting reframes why. Gazzetta dello Sport, relayed by Sport Witness on 17 November, describes the Birmingham City defender as a cheaper alternative to Lecce's Tiago Gabriel, who would cost upwards of €25m. That is the real story here: Neumann is being weighed as the budget option, not a priority target in his own right. Dennis Bayer's earlier report had Fiorentina named alongside Nottingham and other unnamed clubs merely gathering information on the 29 year old centre back, who has played every Championship game for Birmingham this season.
The reporting
Bayer first reported it on 10 November, citing Sky sources and putting Neumann's valuation at €5-10m.Sport Witness's update a week later adds the Gabriel comparison but is repeating the Gazzetta line rather than breaking new ground, so this remains one voice rather than several independently confirming interest. No outlet has matched the story with separate sourcing of its own.
The outlook
What would actually move this on is Fiorentina missing out on Gabriel or similar targets, forcing them toward cheaper options when the January window opens on 1 January. Until a club makes an actual offer for Neumann, this stays speculative interest dressed up as a plan.
Sources the analyst weighedDennis BayerTrust72Sport WitnessTrust55